Abstract
The paper addresses some of the challenging legal issues invoked by the response of the part of the international community to the Russian aggression in Ukraine in 2022. These legal issues were selected through the lenses of evolution versus caution paradigm. In particular, it maps the issue of the permissibility of third-party countermeasures, a topic that has already enjoyed attention of the doctrine but is still controversial. It then focuses on the issue of confiscation of frozen Russian assets as a possible form of countermeasure. This issue is addressed through the optics of the human right to private property and briefly also through the lenses of the law on the immunities of States. The paper then addresses a complicated issue of possible claims against sanctions initiated in international investment arbitration. It focuses primarily on the question whether host States can raise the defence of countermeasures in investment arbitration.
References
- Literature and electronic sources Search in Google Scholar
- AKEHURST, Michael. Reprisals by Third States. [online]. Available at: <http://heinonline.org/HOL/ Search in Google Scholar
- LandingPage?handle=hein.journals/byrint44&div=4&id=&page=> Accessed: 01.12.2023. Search in Google Scholar
- ALEXANDROS-CĂTĂLIN, Bakos, KABIR, Duggal A.N. Economic sanctions in International Search in Google Scholar
- Investment Arbitration. [online]. Available at <https://jusmundi.com/en/document/publication/ Search in Google Scholar
- en-economic-sanctions-in-international-investment-arbitration> Accessed 05.03.2024. Search in Google Scholar
- ANDERSON, Scott R., KEITNER, Chimène. The Legal Challenges Presented by Seizing Frozen Search in Google Scholar
- Russian Assets. [online]. Available at: <https://www.lawfaremedia.org/article/legal-challengespresented- Search in Google Scholar
- seizing-frozen-russian-assets> Accessed: 04.01.2024. Search in Google Scholar
- BACZYNSKA, Gabriela. No quick EU path to give Ukraine profits on sanctioned Russian assets. Search in Google Scholar
- [online]. Available at: <https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/no-quick-eu-path-give-ukraineprofits- Search in Google Scholar
- sanctioned-russian-assets-2023-12-08/> Accessed: 04.10.2023. Search in Google Scholar
- Belgium may face treaty arbitration over sanctioned Russian assets. [online]. Available at: Search in Google Scholar
- www.iareporter.com/articles/belgium-may-face-treaty-arbitration-over-sanctioned-russianassets/> Search in Google Scholar
- Accessed 04.03.2024. Search in Google Scholar
- BRUNK, Ingrid, Wuerth. Countermeasures and Confiscation of Russian Central Bank Assets. [online]. Search in Google Scholar
- Available at: <https://www.lawfaremedia.org/article/countermeasures-and-the-confiscation-ofrussian- Search in Google Scholar
- central-bank-assets> Accessed: 03.03.2024. Search in Google Scholar
- BUTLER, Nicolette. The Effect of Unilateral Sanctions on the Foreign Investment Law Regime. Search in Google Scholar
- In: SUBEDI, Surya P. (ed). Unilateral Sanctions in International Law. Hart Publishing, 2021, Search in Google Scholar
- pp. 161–183. Search in Google Scholar
- Canada will transfer confiscated Antonov An-124 from Volga-Dnepr to Ukraine. [online]. Available Search in Google Scholar
- at: <https://www.aerotime.aero/articles/canada-will-transfer-confiscated-antonov-an-124-fromvolga- Search in Google Scholar
- dnepr-to-ukraine> Accessed: 12.01.2024. Search in Google Scholar
- CASSESE, Antonio. International Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001. Search in Google Scholar
- CUJO, Eglantine. Invocation of Responsibility by International Organizations. In Crawford, James Search in Google Scholar
- (ed). The Law of International Responsibility. New York, 2010, pp. 969–984. Search in Google Scholar
- DAWIDOWICZ, Martin. Third-Party Countermeasures in International Law. Cambridge University Search in Google Scholar
- Press, 2017. Search in Google Scholar
- DAWIDOWICZ, Martin. Third-party countermeasures: A progressive development of international Search in Google Scholar
- law? Questions of International Law, 2016, No. 29, pp. 3–15. Search in Google Scholar
- DAWIDOWICZ, Martin. Third-party countermeasures. Observations on a controversial concept. Search in Google Scholar
- In CHINKIN, Christine, BAETENS, Freya (eds). Sovereignty, Statehood and State Responsibility. Search in Google Scholar
- Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2015, pp. 340–362. Search in Google Scholar
- ECtHR. Information Note No. 76 on the case-law of the Court (June 2005). [online]. Available at: Search in Google Scholar
- www.echr.coe.int/documents/d/echr/CLIN_2005_06_76_ENG_822320> Accessed: 01.10.2023. Search in Google Scholar
- EU Policy. Brussels rows back on plan to tax €200 bn in frozen Russian assets. [online]. Available Search in Google Scholar
- at: <https://www.euronews.com/my-europe/2023/12/12/brussels-rows-back-on-plan-to-tax-200- Search in Google Scholar
- bn-in-frozen-russian-assets> Accessed: 01.12.2023. Search in Google Scholar
- EU vyzývá členské státy ke konfiskaci majetku ruských oligarchů. [online]. Available at: Search in Google Scholar
- ceskatelevize.cz/svet/3477630-eurokomisar-pro-justici-eu-vyzyva-clenske-staty-ke-konfiskacimajetku- Search in Google Scholar
- ruskych-oligarchu> Accessed: 03.03.2024. Search in Google Scholar
- European Commission positive on Estonia’s Russian asset seizure initiative. [online]. Available at: Search in Google Scholar
- <https://news.err.ee/1608849637/european-commission-positive-on-estonia-s-russian-assetseizure-
- initiative> Accessed: 12.01.2024. Search in Google Scholar
- European Commission. EU Sanctions map. [online]. Available at: <https://www.sanctionsmap.eu/#/ Search in Google Scholar
- main> Accessed: 03.03.2024. Search in Google Scholar
- GORDON, Richard, John, Francis and others. Sanctions Law. Oxford, Portland: Hart Publishing, 2019. Search in Google Scholar
- GRIERSON, Jamie, MASON, Rowena. Property of Russian elites could be handed to Ukrainian Search in Google Scholar
- refugees. [online]. 4 March 2022. Available at: <https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/ Search in Google Scholar
- mar/04/property-of-russian-elites-could-be-handed-to-ukrainian-refugees-says-raab> Accessed: Search in Google Scholar
- 03.2024. Search in Google Scholar
- HILLGRUBER, Christian. The Right of Third States to Take Countermeasures. In TOMUSCHAT, Search in Google Scholar
- Cristian, THOUVENIN, Jean-Marc (eds). The Fundamental Rules of the International Legal Order. Search in Google Scholar
- Brill, 2005, pp. 265–293. Search in Google Scholar
- In confiscating frozen Russian assets, Estonia may follow Canadian example. [online]. Available at: Search in Google Scholar
- <https://news.err.ee/1608872648/in-confiscating-frozen-russian-assets-estonia-may-followcanadian-
- example> Accessed: 12.11.2023. Search in Google Scholar
- Justice Department Transfers Approximately $500,000 in Forfeited Russian Funds to Estonia for Benefit Search in Google Scholar
- of Ukraine. [online]. Available at: <https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-transfersapproximately- Search in Google Scholar
- -forfeited-russian-funds-estonia-benefit> Accessed: 03.03.2024. Search in Google Scholar
- KAMMINGA, Menno T. Confiscating Russia´s Frozen Central Bank Assets: A Permissible Third- Search in Google Scholar
- Party Countermeasure? Netherlands International Law Review, 2022, vol. 70, pp. 1–17. Search in Google Scholar
- KAPLAN, Juliana and others. Congress tees up a plan to seize Russian yachts and properties in the US — Search in Google Scholar
- and sell them for Ukraine aid. [online]. Available at: <https://www.businessinsider.com/congressbill- Search in Google Scholar
- seize-russian-yachts-sell-for-ukraine-aid-2022-3?r=US&IR=T> Accessed: 03.03.2024. Search in Google Scholar
- LOSARI, Junianto, James, EWING-CHOW, Michael. A clash of treaties: The lawfulness of Search in Google Scholar
- Countermeasures in International Trade Law and International Investment Law. The Journal of Search in Google Scholar
- World Investment & Trade, 2015, vol. 16, pp. 274–313. Search in Google Scholar
- Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Czech Republic. Three more entities were added to the national Search in Google Scholar
- sanction list. [online]. Available at: <https://mzv.gov.cz/jnp/en/issues_and_press/press_releases/ Search in Google Scholar
- three_more_entities_were_added_to_the.html> Accessed: 12.12.2023. Search in Google Scholar
- MOECKLI, Daniel, and others (eds). International Human Rights Law. 3rd ed. Oxford University Search in Google Scholar
- Press, 2017. Search in Google Scholar
- MOISEIENKO, Anton. Legal: The Freezing of the Russian Central Bank’s Assets. European Journal of Search in Google Scholar
- International Law, 2023, vol. 34, no. 4, pp. 1007–1020. Search in Google Scholar
- No quick EU path to give Ukraine profits on sanctioned Russian assets. [online]. Available at: Search in Google Scholar
- www.reuters.com/world/europe/no-quick-eu-path-give-ukraine-profits-sanctioned-russianassets- Search in Google Scholar
- -12-08/> Accessed: 01.12.2023. Search in Google Scholar
- OLMEDO, Javier, Garcia. The Legality of EU Sanctions under International Investment Agreements. Search in Google Scholar
- European Foreign Affairs Review, 2023, vol. 28, pp. 95–116. Search in Google Scholar
- PALCHETTI, Paolo. Consequences for Third States as a Result of an Unlawful Use of Force. Search in Google Scholar
- In WELLER, Marc (ed). The Oxford Handbook on the Use of Force in International Law. Oxford Search in Google Scholar
- University Press, 2015, pp. 1224–1238. Search in Google Scholar
- PAPARINSKINS, M. Circumstances Precluding Wrongfulness in International Investment Law. Search in Google Scholar
- ICSID Review, 2016, vol. 31, pp. 484–503. Search in Google Scholar
- PARLETT, Kate. The Application of the rules on countermeasures in investment claims. Search in Google Scholar
- In CHINKIN, Christine, BAETENS, Freya (eds). Sovereignty, Statehood and State Responsibility. Search in Google Scholar
- Essays in Honour of James Crawford. Cambridge University Press, 2015, pp. 389–405. Search in Google Scholar
- PELLET, Alain, MIRON, Alina. Sanctions. [online]. Available at: <https://opil.ouplaw.com/display/10.1093/ Search in Google Scholar
- law:epil/9780199231690/law-9780199231690-e984?prd=MPIL> Accessed: 03.03.2023. Search in Google Scholar
- PM: Ukraine prepares for confiscation of Russian assets, receives first 17B. [online]. Available at: Search in Google Scholar
- <https://www.ukrinform.net/rubric-economy/3677837-pm-ukraine-prepares-for-confiscationof-
- russian-assets-receives-first-17b.html> Accessed: 12.12.2023. Search in Google Scholar
- ROBERT-CUENDET, Sabrina. Unilateral and extraterritorial sanctions and international investment Search in Google Scholar
- law. In BEAUCILLON, Charlotte (ed). Research Handbook on Unilateral and Extraterritorial Search in Google Scholar
- Sanctions. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 2021, pp. 204-220. Search in Google Scholar
- Russian firm escalates dispute with Canada over seized cargo plane. [online]. Available at: Search in Google Scholar
- cbc.ca/news/politics/russia-antonov-plane-pearson-ukraine-1.6939473> Accessed: 01.11.2023. Search in Google Scholar
- RUYS, Tom. Sanctions, retorsions and countermeasures: concepts and international legal framework. Search in Google Scholar
- In HERIK, Larissa van den (ed). Research Handbook on UN Sanctions and International Law, Search in Google Scholar
- Northampton, 2017, pp. 19–51. Search in Google Scholar
- SILVEIRA, Mercédeh, Azeredo, LEVASHOVA, Yulia. Economic Sanctions, Countermeasures and Search in Google Scholar
- Investment Claims against the Russian Federation: A Battle on Multiple Fronts. ICSID Review, Search in Google Scholar
- , pp. 1–15. Search in Google Scholar
- SOUTH KOREA ROUND-UP: LONE STAR FILES FOR ANNULMENT, IRAN’S CENTRAL BANK Search in Google Scholar
- TO START ARBITRATION OVER 7+ BILLION USD IN FROZEN ASSETS, AND A LOOK AT THE Search in Google Scholar
- IMPACT OF RUSSIA’S INVASION OF UKRAINE ON KOREAN BUSINESS. [online]. Available Search in Google Scholar
- at: <https://www.iareporter.com/articles/south-korea-round-up-lone-star-files-for-annulmentirans- Search in Google Scholar
- central-bank-to-start-arbitration-over-7-billion-usd-in-frozen-assets-and-a-look-at-theimpact- Search in Google Scholar
- of-the-russia-ukraine-war-on-korean/> Accessed: 01.11.2023. Search in Google Scholar
- South Korea says Iran’s frozen funds transferred to a third country. [online]. Available at: Search in Google Scholar
- <https://www.reuters.com/world/south-korea-says-irans-frozen-funds-transferred-thirdcountry-
- -09-18/> Accessed: 01.11.2023. Search in Google Scholar
- STEJSKAL, Petr, FAIX, Martin. Sanctions from the Perspective of the Right to Property – Confiscation Search in Google Scholar
- of Assets. In ŠTURMA, Pavel (ed). International Sanctions and Human Rights. Springer, 2024, Search in Google Scholar
- pp. 155-175. Search in Google Scholar
- STEJSKAL, Petr. Sankce v mezinárodním právu ve světle ukrajinské krize – jak fungují, jaké jsou pro Search in Google Scholar
- ně podmínky a jak se provádí v ČR. Jurisprudence, 2022, No. 5, pp. 11–25. Search in Google Scholar
- STHOEGER, Eran, TAMS, Christian J. Swords, Shields and Other Beasts: The Role of Search in Google Scholar
- Countermeasures in Investment Arbitration. ICSID Review, 2022, vol. 37, no. 1–2, pp. 121–137. Search in Google Scholar
- ŠTURMA, Pavel. Nesnesitelná lehkost sankcí? Zamyšlení nad aktuálním problémem z pohledu Search in Google Scholar
- mezinárodního práva. In Špaček, Metod (ed). Medzinárodné právo jako strážca svetového Search in Google Scholar
- pozadku: Vynútiteľnosť medzinárodného práva v 21. storočí. Bratislava: Slovenská spoločnosť pre Search in Google Scholar
- medzinárodné právo při SAV, 2014, pp. 51–61. Search in Google Scholar
- The Economist. Could seizing Russian assets help rebuild Ukraine? [online]. Available at: Search in Google Scholar
- www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2022/06/06/could-seizing-russian-assets-helprebuild- Search in Google Scholar
- ukraine> Accessed: 01.12.2023. Search in Google Scholar
- THOUVENIN, Jean-Marc. Gel des fonds des banques centrales et immunité d’exécution. Search in Google Scholar
- In PETERS, Anne and others (eds). Immunities in the Age of Global Constitutionalism, 2015, Search in Google Scholar
- pp. 209–219. Search in Google Scholar
- Tracking sanctions against Russia. [online]. Available at: <https://graphics.reuters.com/UKRAINECRISIS/ Search in Google Scholar
- SANCTIONS/byvrjenzmve/> Accessed: 14.01.2024. Search in Google Scholar
- Two Russian Banks Threaten Treaty Arbitration. [online]. Available at: <https://www.iareporter.com/ Search in Google Scholar
- articles/two-russian-banks-threaten-treaty-arbitration-against-ukraine-following-seizure-oftheir- Search in Google Scholar
- assets-in-the-context-of-the-ongoing-russia-ukraine-war/> Accessed: 12.12.2023. Search in Google Scholar
- UN International Law Commission. Draft Articles on Responsibility of States for Internationally Search in Google Scholar
- Wrongful Acts. Report of the International Law Commission on the Work of Its Fifty-third Search in Google Scholar
- Session, UN GAOR, 56th Sess., Supp. No. 10, at 43, UN Doc. A/56/10 (2001). Search in Google Scholar
- UN International Law Commission. Yearbook of the International Law Commission, Vol. II, Part Two. Search in Google Scholar
- Draft articles on Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts, with commentaries, 2001. Search in Google Scholar
- [UPDATED] RUSSIAN AIRLINE FILES NOTICE OF DISPUTE OVER CANADA’S DECISION TO Search in Google Scholar
- SEIZE AIRCRAFT. [online]. Available at: <https://www.iareporter.com/articles/russian-airlinefiles- Search in Google Scholar
- notice-of-dispute-over-canadas-decision-to-seize-aircraft/> Accessed: 01.11.2023. Search in Google Scholar
- [UPDATED] RUSSIAN INVESTORS ARE REPORTEDLY CONTEMPLATING TREATY CLAIMS Search in Google Scholar
- OVER FREEZING OF THEIR ASSETS HELD BY EUROPEAN CENTRAL SECURITIES Search in Google Scholar
- DEPOSITORIES. [online]. Available at: <https://www.iareporter.com/articles/russian-investorsare- Search in Google Scholar
- reportedly-contemplating-treaty-claims-over-sanctions-based-freezing-of-their-assets-heldby- Search in Google Scholar
- european-central-securities-depositories/> 01.11.2023. Search in Google Scholar
- US transfers seized assets from sanctions-hit oligarch to send to Ukraine. [online]. Available at: Search in Google Scholar
- www.ft.com/content/ef3501bf-c498-4597-bec3-c284daf9ac2b> Accessed: 03.03.2024. Search in Google Scholar
- Věra Jourová at the Czech National TV (ČT24, Otázky Václava Moravce, 22. April 2022. Search in Google Scholar
- Available at: <https://www.ceskatelevize.cz/porady/1126672097-otazky-vaclava-moravce/ Search in Google Scholar
- />. Search in Google Scholar
- ZRILIČ, Jure. Are We in for a New Wave of Investment Arbitrations? Russia’s Measures Against Foreign Search in Google Scholar
- Investors and Investment Treaty Implications. [online]. Available at: <https://verfassungsblog.de/ Search in Google Scholar
- are-we-in-for-a-new-wave-of-investment-arbitrations/> Accessed: 04.02.1992. Search in Google Scholar
- Legal documents Search in Google Scholar
- Agreement between the Government of Russian Federation and the Government of the Czech Search in Google Scholar
- Republic on promotion and protection of foreign investments from 1994. Search in Google Scholar
- Accord entre les Gouvernements du Royaume de Belgique et du Grand duché de Luxembourg et le Search in Google Scholar
- Governement de l’Union des républiques socialistes soviétiques, concernant l’encouragement et la Search in Google Scholar
- protection réciproque des investissements, 1989. Search in Google Scholar
- Council Regulation (EU) No. 269/2014 of 17 March 2014 (amended version). Search in Google Scholar
- Czech Republic. Act No. 1/2023 Coll., on Restrictive Measures against Certain Serious Conduct Search in Google Scholar
- applied in International Relations (Sanctions Act). Search in Google Scholar
- Special Economic Measures Act. S. C. 1992, c. 17. The Act is available at: <https://laws-lois.justice. Search in Google Scholar
- gc.ca/eng/acts/S-14.5/page-1.html>. Search in Google Scholar
- Court decisions Search in Google Scholar
- Archer Daniels Midland Company v. Mexico, ICSID Case No. ARB(AF)/04/05, Award of Search in Google Scholar
- November 2007. Search in Google Scholar
- Cargill, Inc. v. Mexico, ICSID Case No. ARB(AF)/05/02, Award of 18 September 2009. Search in Google Scholar
- Case Concerning United States Diplomatic and Consular Staff in Tehran (United States of America v. Search in Google Scholar
- Iran), ICJ, Judgement, 24 May 1980. Search in Google Scholar
- Certain Iranian Assets (Islamic Republic of Iran v. United States of America), ICJ, Judgement, Search in Google Scholar
- March 2023. Search in Google Scholar
- ECtHR. Jahn and Others v. Germany, no. 46720/99, 72203/99 and 72552/01, Judgement, Search in Google Scholar
- June 2005. Search in Google Scholar
- ECtHR. Lithgow and others v. the United Kingdom, no. 9006/80, 9262/81, 9263/81, 9265/81, 9266/81, Search in Google Scholar
- /81, 9405/81, Judgement, 8 June 1986. Search in Google Scholar
- ECtHR. The Holy Monasteries v. Greece, no. 13092/87; 13984/88, Judgement, 9 December 1994. Search in Google Scholar
- Gabčíkovo-Nagymaros (Hungary v. Slovakia), ICJ, Judgement, 25 September 1997. Search in Google Scholar
- General Court (CJEU), Case T-270/22, Judgement, 6 September 2023. Search in Google Scholar
