Abstract
Proportionality is a fundamental principle of criminal law. The issue whether the application of criminal liability to patients and doctors for participating in illegal gift “transactions” with the use of descriptive, analytical, logical, and comparative methods was examined. Focusing on utilitarianism and retributivism, the content of proportionality was presented: the balance between benefit to society and harm to the offender, the effectiveness of punishment, the implementation of justice as retribution, and the dangerousness of the offence and the offender. The conclusion was made that the criminal liability for gratitude gifts in the healthcare system is not proportionate. Consequently, recommendations were made for the establishment of disciplinary or administrative liability for symbolic gifts of gratitude in the healthcare sector of Lithuania.
References
- ANDERECK, William. Yes: If they are Given Out of Beneficence Or Appreciation. The Western Journal of Medicine, 2001, vol. 175, no. 2, p. 76. Search in Google Scholar
- BENTHAM, Jeremy. An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation. Kitchener: Batoche Books, 2000. Search in Google Scholar
- BERENTA, Juozas. Tarp kyšio policininkui ir vokelio gydytojui nėra jokio skirtumo (There is no Difference between a Bribe to a Policeman and an Envelope to a Doctor). [online]. Available at: <https://www.delfi.lt/verslas/verslas/j-berenta-tarp-kysio-policininkui-ir-vokelio-gydytojui-nera-jokio-skirtumo-61604783> Accessed: 15.04.2024. Search in Google Scholar
- BINDER, Guyora, SMITH, Nicholas, J. Framed: Utilitarianism and Punishment of the Innocent. Rutgers LJ, 2000, vol. 32, pp. 115–224. Search in Google Scholar
- BIKELIS, Skirmantas. Rethinking system of sanctions for trafficing of goods: the problem of proportionality (I). Principe of proportionality and criminal sanctions. Teisės problemos, 2012, vol. 78, no. 4, pp. 5–24. Search in Google Scholar
- CARO, Mario De. Utilitarianism and Retributivism in Cesare Beccaria. Italian Law Journal, 2016, vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 1–12. Search in Google Scholar
- CLARKSON, C., M., V. Why Criminal Law? The Role of Utilitarianism: A Response to Husak. Crim Law and Philos, 2008, vol. 2, no. 2, pp. 131–135. Search in Google Scholar
- CORLETT, J., Angelo. Making Sense of Retributivism. Philosophy, 2001, vol. 76, no. 295, pp. 77–110. Search in Google Scholar
- Code of Administrative Offences of the Republic of Lithuania. TAR, 2015, no. 11216. Search in Google Scholar
- Code of Conduct for Employees of Healthcare Institutions, TAR, 2021, no. 16035. Search in Google Scholar
- Council of Europe, Committee of Ministers. Recommendation No. R (91) 1, 1991; ECHR (1950, ETS 5). Search in Google Scholar
- Criminal Code of the Republic of Lithuania. Official Gazette, 2000, no. 89–2741. Search in Google Scholar
- DACHAK, Hadi. The Principle of Proportionality of Crime and Punishment in International Documents. International Journal of Multicultural and Multireligious Understanding, 2021, vol. 8, no. 4, pp. 684–694. Search in Google Scholar
- Draft Law on Supplementing Article 250(2) of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Lithuania, 2001, no. IXP-342(2SP). Search in Google Scholar
- ELTA. Tyrimas: neoficialios dovanos medikams populiaresnės tarp vyresnių gyventojų (Research: Informal Gifts for Doctors are more Popular among the Elderly Population). [online]. Available at: <https://www.lrt.lt/naujienos/sveikata/682/2212965/tyrimas-neoficialios-dovanos-medikams-populiaresnes-tarp-vyresniu-gyventoju> Accessed: 03.03.2024. Search in Google Scholar
- EMIGHOLZ, Carl. Utilitarianism, Retributivism and the White Collar-Drug Crime Sentencing Disparity: Toward a Unified Theory of Enforcement. Rutgers Law Review, 2006, vol. 58, no. 2, pp. 583–614. Search in Google Scholar
- ENGLE, Eric. The History of the General Principle of Proportionality: An Overview. Dartmouth Law Journal, 2012, vol. 10, no. 1, pp. 1–11. Search in Google Scholar
- European Commission. Special Eurobarometer 534. Luxembourg: Publications Office, 2023. Search in Google Scholar
- FISH, Morris, J. An Eye for an Eye: Proportionality as a Moral Principle of Punishment. Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, 2008, vol. 28, no. 1, pp. 57–71. Search in Google Scholar
- FRASE, Richard. Punishment Purposes. STAN. L. REV, 2005, vol. 58, no. 67, pp. 67–84. Search in Google Scholar
- GRAY, David. Punishment as Suffering. Vanderbilt Law Review, 2010, vol. 63, no. 6, pp. 1619–1693. Search in Google Scholar
- HAIST, Matthew. Deterrence in a Sea of Just Deserts: Are Utilitarian Goals Achievable in a World of Limiting Retributivism. J. Crim. L. & Criminology, 2009, vol. 99, no. 3, pp. 789–822. Search in Google Scholar
- HIRSCH, Andrew von. Proportionality in the Philosophy of Punishment. Crime and Justice, 1992, vol. 16, pp. 55–98. Search in Google Scholar
- KARGAUDIENĖ, Aušra. Principle of proportionality in administrative law and its application in Lithuanian courts. Jurisprudencija, 2005, vol. 78, no. 70, pp. 29–38. Search in Google Scholar
- LATINYTĖ, Rūta. Gift-giving as an expression of interpersonal relations in everyday practices in Lithuania at the end of the 20th – beginning of the 21st century. Doctoral thesis, Vilnius University, Vilnius, 2022. Search in Google Scholar
- Law on the Civil Service of the Republic of Lithuania. Official Gazette, 1999, no. 66–2130. Search in Google Scholar
- LETSAS, George. Proportionality as Fittingness: The Moral Dimension of Proportionality. Current Legal Problems, 2018, vol. 71, no. 1, pp. 53–86. Search in Google Scholar
- Lithuania v. A.Ž. Supreme Court of Lithuania. Judgment of 23 February 2022. Application no. 2K-35-719/2022. Search in Google Scholar
- Lithuania v. I.P., I.A., Ž.L. Supreme Court of Lithuania. Judgment of 3 November 2020. Application no. 2K-221-942/2020. Search in Google Scholar
- Lithuania v. K.D. Supreme Court of Lithuania. Judgment of 3 February 2022. Application no. 2K-23-628/2022. Search in Google Scholar
- Lithuania v. R.K. et al. Court of Appeal of Lithuania. Judgment of 22 November 2023. Application no. 1A-40-307/2023. Search in Google Scholar
- Lithuania v. R.P. Supreme Court of Lithuania. Judgment of 10 November 2015. Application no. 2K-P-100-222/2015. Search in Google Scholar
- Lithuania v. R.T. et al. Supreme Court of Lithuania. Judgment of 27 December 2007. Application no. 2K-594/2007. Search in Google Scholar
- Lithuania v. V.R. Supreme Court of Lithuania. Judgment of 29 December 2016. Application no. 2K-449-942/2016. Search in Google Scholar
- Lithuania v. V.Š. Court of Appeal of Lithuania. Judgment of 28 February 2024. Application no. 1A-166-870/2024. Search in Google Scholar
- MACKAY, Kathryn. Rules and Resistance: A Commentary on “An Archeology of Corruption in Medicine”. Journal of Bioethical Inquiry, 2022, vol. 19, no. 1, pp. 123–127. Search in Google Scholar
- MALINAUSKAS, Vygantas. Theoretical and methodological aspects of ensuring a balance between human rights and public interest. Doctoral thesis, Vytautas Magnus University, Kaunas, 2018. Search in Google Scholar
- MONRO, Charles, Henry (trans). The Digest of Justinian. Cambridge University Press, 1904. Search in Google Scholar
- POSNER, Richard, A. An Economic Theory of the Criminal Law. Columbia Law Review, 1985, vol. 85, no. 6, pp. 1193–1231. Search in Google Scholar
- R. v. M. (CA). [1996] 1 SCR 500 (Canadian case). Search in Google Scholar
- ROBINSON, Paul, H. Distributive Principles of Criminal Law: Who Should be Punished How Much. University of Pennsylvania, 2008. Search in Google Scholar
- The ruling of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Lithuania of 2 October 2001. Official Gazette, 2001, no. 85–2977. Search in Google Scholar
- The ruling of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Lithuania of 6 December 2000. Official Gazette, 2000, no. 105–3318. Search in Google Scholar
- The ruling of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Lithuania of 10 November 2005. Official Gazette, 2005, no. 134–4819. Search in Google Scholar
- The ruling of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Lithuania of 13 December 2004. Official Gazette, 2004, no. 181–6708. Search in Google Scholar
- The ruling of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Lithuania of 29 December 2004. Official Gazette, 2005, no. 1–7. Search in Google Scholar
- The ruling of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Lithuania of 29 September 2005. Official Gazette, 2005, no. 117–4239. Search in Google Scholar
- SAKALAUSKAS, Gintautas, BIKELIS, Skirmantas, KALPOKAS, Vaidas, POCIENĖ, Aušra. Criminal Policy in Lithuania: Trends and Comparative Aspects. Vilnius: Law Institute of Lithuania, 2012. Search in Google Scholar
- SINKEVIČIUS, Vytautas. Principles and limits of interpretation of the Constitution. Jurisprudencija, 2005, vol. 67, no. 59, pp. 7–19. Search in Google Scholar
- SLOT, Brigitte, SWART, Linette de, WEISTRA, Kim, OORTWIJN, Wija, WANROOIJ, Niels van, RAETS, Tess. Updated Study on Corruption in the Healthcare Sector. Luxembourg: Publications Office, 2017. Search in Google Scholar
- SPECTOR, Horacio. Constitutional proportionality and moral deontology. Jurisprudence, 2021, vol. 12, no. 4, pp. 1–25. Search in Google Scholar
- SUMMERS, Robert, S. H.L.A. Hart on Justice. The Journal of Philosophy, 1962, vol. 59, no. 18, pp. 497–500. Search in Google Scholar
- ŠEDBARAS, Stasys. Administracinė atsakomybė (Administrative Liability). Vilnius: Justitia, 2005. Search in Google Scholar
- TOPCHII, Vasyl, ZADEREIKO, Svitlana, DIDKIVSKA, Galyna, BODUNOVA, Olesia, SHEVCHENKO, Dmytro. International Anti-Corruption Standards. Baltic Journal of Economic Studies, 2021, vol. 7, no. 5, pp. 277–286. Search in Google Scholar
- VALANČIUS, Virgilijus, NORKUS, Rimvydas. Aspects of Contact of Administrative and Criminal Justice in Lithuania. Jurisprudencija, 2006, vol. 82, no. 4, pp. 91–98. Search in Google Scholar
- ZHU, Jiangnan. Do Severe Penalties Deter Corruption? A Game Theoretic Analysis of the Chinese Case. China Review, 2012, vol. 12, no. 2, pp. 1–32. Search in Google Scholar
